Skip to main content

FRAMES logo
Resource Catalog

Document

Type: Journal Article
Author(s): Gary B. Snider; Peter J. Daugherty; Donald B. Wood
Publication Date: 2006

ANNOTATION: This study shows that without large-scale implementation of fire hazard reduction treatments, the costs of uncharacteristic crown fires in southwest forests will continue to increase. They examined the economic rationality of continuing this policy of emphasizing fire suppression activities over restoration-based fire hazard reduction treatments. They compared treatment plus fire suppression costs to the cost of fire suppression without treatments over 40 years for southwestern forests. This avoided-cost analysis estimates the amount one could invest in treatments to avoid the future cost of fire suppression. ABSTRACT: Without large-scale implementation of fire hazard reduction treatments, the costs of uncharacteristic crown fires in southwest forests will continue to increase. Federal policy continues to allocate vastly more funds to suppression than to prefire hazard reduction. We examined the economic rationality of continuing this policy of emphasizing fire suppression activities over restoration-based fire hazard reduction treatments. We compared treatment plus fire suppression costs to the cost of fire suppression without treatments over 40 years for southwestern forests. This avoided-cost analysis estimates the amount one could invest in treatments to avoid the future cost of fire suppression. Using conservative economic values, we found that avoided future costs justifies spending $238-601/ac for hazard reduction treatments in the southwest. We conclude that the policy of underfunding hazard reduction treatments does not represent rational economic behavior, because funding hazard reduction would pay for itself by lowering future fire suppression costs.

Online Links
Citation: Snider, Gary B.; Daugherty, Peter J.; Wood, Donald B. 2006. The irrationality of continued fire suppression: an avoided cost analysis of fire hazard reduction treatments verses no treatment. Journal of Forestry 104(8):431-437.

Cataloging Information

Regions:
Partner Sites:
Keywords:
  • cost analysis
  • fire hazard reduction
Record Last Modified:
Record Maintained By: FRAMES Staff (https://www.frames.gov/contact)
FRAMES Record Number: 7628